“People need dramatic examples to shake them out of apathy, and I can’t do that as Bruce Wayne. As a man, I’m flesh and blood. I can be ignored, I can be destroyed. But as a symbol? As a symbol I can be incorruptible, I can be everlasting.” — Bruce Wayne (Christian Bale)
The page was turned on Batman Begins quite quickly, as I recall. Director Christopher Nolan made another movie the following year called The Prestige that also prominently featured Christian Bale and Michael Caine, and I can remember seeing commercials for it and hearing people say, “So is that supposed to be another Batman Begins or what?” Batman Begins also had the misfortune of being immediately (and completely) overshadowed by its successor, particularly once Heath Ledger passed away six months ahead of The Dark Knight‘s July 2008 release. Begins also came on the heels of an extended drought: it had been eight years since the previous Batman film, Joel Schumacher’s atrocious Batman & Robin, which could be — and this is not hyperbole — one of the very worst movies ever released by a major Hollywood studio. Schumacher’s 1997 fiasco — featuring nipple suits, painfully bad Arnold Schwarznezegger one-liners (for which he was paid $20 million to deliver) and ’70s camp set to cheese overload — was many things, but above all it had the distinction of, for eight long years, killing the Batman film franchise.
For younger cinephiles, this bit of history is likely impossible to even conceive, considering The Dark Knight and The Dark Knight Rises each grossed over $1 billion in worldwide box office receipts. In fact, I didn’t even see Batman Begins in theaters, despite hearing that it was actually good. Frankly, I just wasn’t interested. (Though to be honest, I didn’t see that many movies in theaters back then.) Batman had pretty much no pop culture value when Batman Begins hit theaters, which goes a long way towards explaining its relatively paltry $374 million worldwide box office take. (With a $150 million budget, that means the movie barely broke even, if it managed to do so at all.) Even given proper context and the benefit of 20/20 hindsight, it’s still shocking in retrospect that Batman Begins only managed to gross a third of what its sequels managed. But that’s how badly Batman & Robin broke the franchise: it was thought to be, like Gotham in Batman Begins, beyond saving. Nobody wanted more Batman in 2005, until everybody eventually saw Batman Begins and said, “Oh wow, these movies can actually be good!” Unlike its sequels, Batman Begins was not an event; the word of mouth built slowly over the course of two or three years. By the time Heath Ledger died, everyone was on the same page: we were all looking forward to the second film.
In retrospect, the tendency for most fans has been to consider Batman Begins inferior to The Dark Knight. Much of this view is circumstantial — the bluster and the noise of “the moment” when The Dark Knight was released was incredible — while the rest of it is likely due to the fact that Begins is an origin story and is often viewed as less than a Batman film, or at least less than what a Christopher Nolan-directed Batman film can be. I can certainly understand this point of view, but I think it’s a mistake to not give Batman Begins its proper due, considering it’s such an important film for a lot of different reasons: It launched Nolan’s career as a director of ambitious, max-budget blockbusters; it brought the Batman franchise back from the dead; and, most influentially, it perfected the modern origin story. Batman Begins completely redefined how to do an origin story for a character everyone in the audience thinks they are already familiar with (unlike Spider-Man, Batman had already logged considerable screen time over the years), and has been arguably the most influential film of Nolan’s trilogy — even if it has also received arguably the least acclaim. (Just one Oscar nomination for Cinematography, which was well deserved.)
Batman Begins caused a stir in Hollywood: if Batman could be brought back from the dead, surely other studio properties could be, too. The number of origin stories that started popping up immediately following Batman Begins‘ release were many (it was as if every studio took a look at all of their franchises and said, “Hey, let’s find a way to reboot all these series since they’re pre-sold!”), with Casino Royale (2006) being the earliest and most prominent of the bunch. Other high-profile reboots included The Incredible Hulk (2008), Star Trek (2009), Terminator Salvation (2009), and X-Men Origins: Wolverine (2009). Hell, the Superman franchise was even rebooted in 2013 with Man of Steel, which Christopher Nolan executive produced. (And let’s not forget that freaking Spider-Man received a reboot just ten years after the original debuted.) It’s interesting, though, that when you go over that list of reboots I provided above, most of them flopped and didn’t receive direct sequels. The most successful films were Casino Royale and Star Trek, two movies that didn’t crush at the box office but were received very favorably by critics and audiences alike — once they were seen. Look under the hood of Batman Begins, Casino Royale, and Star Trek, and you’ll realize that they’re of similar build: no superpowers are involved for the main character(s).
This is specifically what makes Batman unique in the comic book canon; he isn’t a true superhero since he doesn’t possess superhuman powers at all. Though Batman’s abilities in Batman Begins are still far from realistic, they can at least be attributed to a reasonably plausible source: the Applied Sciences department of Wayne Enterprises. Every new skill or gadget Batman acquires and adds to his tool belt is at least given some kind of explanation and proper set up by the invaluable Lucius Fox (Morgan Freeman), who serves as the equivalent of the James Bond series’ Q here. The failings of the previous four Batman installments — Tim Burton’s Batman (1989) and Batman Returns (1992), as well as Joel Schumacher’s Batman Forever (1995) and Batman & Robin (1997) — always were in their tendency to play squarely into the character’s limitations: Burton and Schumacher each gave the Batman universe hideously over-the-top treatments that were not the slightest bit realistic and were basically cartoonish. In other words, Batman, with no superhuman skills, was severely limited in his own world, which made absolutely no sense whatsoever and made for unsatisfying viewing.
Christopher Nolan wisely decided to take the opposite tack, and the result is a new Batman universe that is grounded in character with a more human, realistic perspective. This also means that the more iconic villains and characters explored in the earlier films — the Joker, the Penguin, Catwoman, the Riddler, Two-Face, Robin, Mr. Freeze, Poison Ivy — are not present in Batman Begins, but that’s the point: Batman is front and center, as he should be in an origin story. The entire first act of Batman Begins is dedicated to Bruce Wayne; he doesn’t put on the bat suit until a full hour into the film. Of course, this is a risky gamble, expecting audiences to not get bored when what they have clearly paid to see is a Batman movie. But the film is quite engrossing in the first act, exploring Wayne’s childhood fear of Bats, the guilt he still carries as an adult due to the murder of his parents, and his relationship with his childhood friend (and later Assistant District Attorney), Rachel Dawes (Katie Holmes). As an adult, Bruce also leaves Gotham and disappears (for seven years, no less) so quietly he is declared dead, landing in an Asian prison after engaging in petty thievery with a local criminal organization in order to understand the mindset of a criminal from the inside out.
In order to really understand the psychology of the Batman character, the nature of childhood trauma must be examined. Childhood trauma is the driving force behind addiction and alcoholism, believe it or not; every addict and alcoholic has two things in common: a history of childhood trauma and a genetic history of addiction or alcoholism. Most often, childhood trauma manifests itself in the form of abuse, but there are certainly other instances that can prove traumatic as well, such as having to witness the murder of your parents. Where addiction comes into play is in how the victim copes with living when his or her sense of self has been shattered. For victims of abuse who have the genetic component, too, eventually they use drugs and alcohol to escape the incident(s) that shattered them, and when they use, they achieve a new sense of self — a new normal. This is why addiction is impossible to cure and extremely difficult to treat from a medical perspective: the overwhelming desire to use never disappears — ever — simply because it isn’t possible to reverse the occurrence of a past event or to alter an addict’s genetic makeup. (To read more on the subject, I would recommend Dr. Drew Pinsky’s book Cracked. You’ll never view addicts the same way again.)
As for Bruce Wayne, it would appear he doesn’t have the genetic history to be an addict — we observe him having a drink here and there without habitually needing more. No, Bruce responds to his childhood trauma in a different way — Batman, his version of a new sense of self, is not created via the use of drugs. When Bruce’s parents are murdered, his human development is radically altered, to the extent that he is never comfortable with being Bruce Wayne. Obviously, one of the functions of parenting is acting as a shield for your children, controlling what they are exposed to. When Bruce’s parents are taken from him, he loses that shield, and since his family has such a high profile, he likely suffers from considerable overexposure, causing him to become withdrawn. One of the most interesting aspects of personality typing is the notion that not only does everyone have a specific type, but that everyone also has a shadow type, too. It’s a bit complicated (even the summary on Wikipedia is bogged down with Jungian abstraction), so allow me to elaborate on the shadow type by explaining how I have always understood it: the shadow emerges when you are under stress.
After all, the Myers-Briggs Typing Indicator is all about helping you discern which of the psychological functions — Introversion or Extraversion, Sensing or iNtuition, Thinking or Feeling, Judging or Perceiving — you prefer to use. For example, I prefer Introversion (focusing my energy inward to explore my own ideas) to Extraversion (focusing my energy outward to always involve others), iNtuition (big picture ideas and patterns) to Sensing (concrete facts and details), Feeling (a values-oriented approach seeking harmony and consensus) to Thinking (a logic-oriented approach that seeks consistency), and Perceiving (keeping my options open) to Judging (making decisions quickly). I’m an INFP, yet I have always thought the ISTP description is a pretty good match for me, as well. In effect, I have found that at work I am an ISTP and elsewhere in life I’m an INFP. It was this conclusion that led me to use regressive abstraction and inductively reason that “your shadow type emerges when you are under stress.”
Your Myers-Briggs type consists of four functions; for the INFP, these are: introverted feeling (Fi), extraverted intuition (Ne), introverted sensing (Si), and extraverted thinking (Te). I could go into a lot more detail here about what a lot of this means, but for the purposes of this discussion, all you need to know is that these functions are laid out in order of dominance. This means that the fourth function is an area of weakness, and believe me, extraverted thinking — outward organization — sure is my biggest weakness. At work, though, it’s almost not an issue — the four functions of the ISTP are: introverted thinking (Ti), extraverted sensing (Se), introverted intuition (Ni), and extraverted feeling (Fe). When under stress, you almost by definition can’t utilize your preferred functions (or you wouldn’t feel stressed), so it’s not surprising that, in projecting my shadow personality at work, I actually flip the introversion/extraversion on all of them, and reverse the order to boot. On paper, the ISTP is not only my shadow, but my opposite. In practice, however, the ESTJ is my true opposite, since it’s the inverse of the INFP (i.e., it’s the same functions in reverse order of preference).
What does all this have to do with Batman? Well, everything. I love the psychological richness of Batman Begins. The way Christopher Nolan approached the film was to basically invert the “Spider-Man dynamic” (or so I like to call it since 2002’s Spider-Man put the comic book genre on the map as true 21st century box office gold) of having Peter Parker walk into the equivalent of a Metropolis phone booth and emerge as his alter ego. Over the course of decades, year after year, superhero movie after superhero movie, this is all we saw — it was law. Most crucially — and this must really be emphasized — from 1989 to 1997, this is what we saw from Tim Burton and Joel Schumacher’s Batman films, as well. Instead, what we got with Batman Begins is a Batman whose natural personality is Batman, not Bruce Wayne; Bruce Wayne is the projection, the shadow. In the first act of the film, we are shown a Bruce Wayne that, in flashbacks, never quite knows what to do with himself or how to act and likely never has — he’s not wanted at Princeton any longer, he’s not needed in Gotham, he’s not needed at Wayne Enterprises, he has no family — so he disappears for seven years.
Wayne informs us he does this to learn how criminals think and act, engaging in petty thievery and working with local Asian criminals. But make no mistake, Nolan puts Bruce Wayne in isolation so we can see Wayne forget who he is. Ever since the murder of his parents, Bruce has had to project, and during his disappearance, his true personality finally emerges — off in the Asian country of Bhutan (the sequence was filmed in Iceland, though the actors look Japanese to me, for what it’s worth), Bruce can stop pretending, now that no one expects anything from him. This is also why the film is so interesting in the first act, even with Bruce on the other side of the world: he’s actually allowing himself to be Batman — his true self — here, and as a result the first act never feels disconnected from the rest of the film at all, even if on paper it seems like it should. Woven into the narrative of his incarceration, his recruitment by the League of Shadows, and his explosive escape from the monastery in the mountains are flashbacks of a bat attack after he falls in a well, his parents’ murder, and the release of his parents’ murderer from prison years later after he cooperates extensively with police regarding mob boss Carmine Falcone’s (Tom Wilkinson) criminal operation.
The film opens with Bruce in prison, where he has been tracked down by Henri Ducard (Liam Neeson), who implores him to conquer his fears, master hand-to-hand combat, and join the League of Shadows, an organization that, as we later learn, was responsible for the destruction of cities like Rome and Constantinople — as well as the spread of the bubonic plague, incidentally — that grew decadent and misshapen until they could no longer function. (In related news, 65 million years ago the League of Dust Clouds — as it was called then — caused an asteroid or comet to hit the Yucatán peninsula, causing the dinosaurs to go extinct.) The way Ducard spins it, the League of Shadows provides human civilization with a necessary service: When an empire is ready to fall, the League of Shadows goes in there with the proverbial wrecking ball and does the demolition work so humanity can then rinse and repeat. Ducard informs Bruce at the conclusion of his training that it’s now Gotham’s turn — crime is just plain fuckin’ ballin’ outta control there, and it’s high time to add the city to the League of Shadows’ growing graveyard of empires so the good people of Gotham can start over.
Bruce quickly realizes this isn’t what he signed up for. “I seek the means to fight injustice,” an exhausted Bruce Wayne manages to say after climbing a freaking mountain to reach the League of Shadows’ monastery just before his training officially begins. But justice to Ducard and Ra’s al Ghul (Ken Watanabe) is not justice to Bruce, who wants no part in essentially Noah’s Arking an entire city — his city, no less. Bruce already has an inkling that corruption has long since devastated Gotham, but unlike the League of Shadows, he refuses to believe that his city’s people are irredeemable. Furthermore, he certainly doesn’t agree that beheading a murderer — his final test before he can join the League Shadows — is justice either. “This man should be tried,” Bruce asserts. “By whom? Corrupt bureaucrats?” Ducard shoots back. In a way, Ducard has a point: it’s not exactly a secret that Gotham is corrupt — Bruce knows it, Rachel knows it, and Sgt. Gordon (Gary Oldman), supposedly the only cop in Gotham who isn’t crooked, especially knows it.
The justice system in America only works when its proponents actually adhere to it, and it starts at the top. When those who make the laws (politicians), those who uphold the laws (judges), and those who enforce the laws (cops) are bought and lower the standard for those who have bought them, society suffers. As Rachel tells Bruce just before he disappears early in the film, “[Justice and revenge] are never the same, Bruce. Justice is about harmony. Revenge is about you making yourself feel better, which is why we have an impartial system.” Bruce scoffs at that, informing her, “Your system is broken.” It’s to Bruce’s credit that at the conclusion of his training when he is tasked with beheading a murderer, he actually argues Rachel’s position. (I guess a couple slaps on the face from Katie Holmes will bring anyone to their senses. Plus, he does flee Gotham in shame immediately following that conversation.) No government is perfect, and ours is no different — we are always striving to form a more perfect Union, as they say. I actually found this diatribe by astrophysicist Neil deGrasse Tyson to be great at elaborating upon the current dysfunction of the American system:
My concern about Congress? 57% of the Senate and 38% of the House cite law as their profession. And when you look at law, law is — well, what happens in the courtroom? [The verdict] doesn’t [reward] what’s right, it [rewards] who argues best. …The entire profession is founded on who the best arguers are.
As Tyson illustrates, the justice system is actually far from just: in practice, being a la






